What State has the Easiest Bar Exam to Pass in the Country?
If we look at bar passage rates alone the answer is South Dakota, which had a 93% pass rate last year. However that may not be the full story.
Professor Robert Anderson of Pepperdine has blogged on this subject: “There is a tremendous difference among the states in the difficulty of their bar exams,” he says. “Some bars are so easy you could accidentally get admitted to them by walking too close to the testing center. Some bars are so difficult that the former Stanford Law School dean could fail them.” (That’s something that apparently actually happened.) [source]
While we can look at the bar passage rates for various states, that alone doesn’t tell us the full story because there are considerable differences in the talent pool lining up to take the bar in each state. Recognizing this, Professor Anderson used data of passage rates where the LSAT score average for that same pool of students was was known, to determine a “Bonus Percent” by which other bar exams are easier than the hardest one, California.
I freely admit that I don’t understand how regression analysis works, but the assumption here is that students who scored better on the LSAT are more likely to pass the bar all things being equal. At any rate, it gives us something nice to look at that probably approximates the relative difficulties of various states’ bar examination. I’ve certainly always been told California’s was the hardest so I guess the numbers back that up.
Rank | State Bar Examination | BonusPercent | Calculated Average LSAT | Calculated Passage Rate | Overall Passage Rate |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | California | 0 | 160.68 | 76.85 | 73.41 |
2 | Louisiana | 0.91 | 154.79 | 72.07 | 68.23 |
3 | Washington | 3.90 | 158.12 | 78.27 | 74.54 |
4 | Oregon | 5.05 | 158.83 | 80.11 | 77.96 |
5 | Nevada | 5.19 | 158.09 | 79.53 | 74.28 |
6 | Virginia | 5.56 | 162.82 | 84.47 | 78.73 |
7 | Arkansas | 5.60 | 154.45 | 76.43 | 77.35 |
8 | West Virginia | 5.72 | 153.22 | 75.36 | 77.56 |
9 | Maryland | 7.02 | 159.85 | 83.06 | 80.08 |
10 | Vermont | 8.44 | 155.02 | 79.82 | 82.24 |
11 | New Jersey | 8.98 | 158.65 | 83.86 | 83.12 |
12 | New York | 9.14 | 162.89 | 88.13 | 86.49 |
13 | Rhode Island | 9.28 | 151.53 | 77.29 | 78.90 |
14 | Colorado | 9.88 | 159.64 | 85.72 | 82.58 |
15 | Florida | 10.02 | 154.40 | 80.80 | 78.44 |
16 | South Carolina | 10.29 | 156.01 | 82.62 | 80.41 |
17 | Arizona | 11.27 | 159.26 | 86.74 | 80.83 |
18 | Utah | 11.39 | 160.97 | 88.52 | 87.56 |
19 | Hawaii | 11.43 | 155.99 | 83.74 | 83.30 |
20 | Indiana | 11.46 | 156.78 | 84.54 | 83.01 |
21 | North Carolina | 11.88 | 156.56 | 84.74 | 78.18 |
22 | Texas | 12.27 | 157.86 | 86.38 | 84.38 |
23 | Idaho | 12.56 | 154.32 | 83.26 | 82.31 |
24 | Wyoming | 12.93 | 153.32 | 82.67 | 72.83 |
25 | Kentucky | 13.57 | 156.59 | 86.46 | 84.61 |
26 | Georgia | 14.36 | 160.39 | 90.93 | 85.99 |
27 | Illinois | 14.86 | 159.68 | 90.74 | 89.97 |
28 | Connecticut | 15.32 | 157.32 | 88.92 | 86.64 |
29 | Pennsylvania | 15.49 | 157.20 | 88.97 | 84.61 |
30 | Tennessee | 15.82 | 158.31 | 90.38 | 84.83 |
31 | Ohio | 16.00 | 155.54 | 87.88 | 86.69 |
32 | Maine | 16.06 | 155.29 | 87.70 | 86.58 |
33 | Massachusetts | 16.07 | 158.30 | 90.62 | 90.16 |
34 | Kansas | 16.40 | 155.49 | 88.23 | 89.22 |
35 | New Hampshire | 16.76 | 153.29 | 86.47 | 86.09 |
36 | North Dakota | 17.18 | 151.00 | 84.67 | 83.23 |
37 | Mississippi | 17.31 | 152.64 | 86.39 | 85.35 |
38 | Minnesota | 18.27 | 157.27 | 91.82 | 91.46 |
39 | New Mexico | 18.51 | 155.56 | 90.41 | 87.26 |
40 | Michigan | 18.67 | 151.57 | 86.72 | 84.98 |
41 | Montana | 18.97 | 154.54 | 89.89 | 90.73 |
42 | Iowa | 19.81 | 156.69 | 92.81 | 90.96 |
43 | Missouri | 20.18 | 157.30 | 93.76 | 91.20 |
44 | Oklahoma | 20.73 | 154.49 | 91.60 | 89.85 |
45 | Nebraska | 20.79 | 155.27 | 92.41 | 88.90 |
46 | Alabama | 21.13 | 157.33 | 94.75 | 87.16 |
47 | Wisconsin | 23.51 | 159.66 | 99.37 | 91.83 |
48 | South Dakota | 28.00 | 150.51 | 95.02 | 93.08 |
I hope commenters can provide some idea about how this chart matches up with local perception of bar exam difficulty. Two things I know are that my classmates considered the Illinois bar relatively easy. Generally we thought it was far and away more easy than the bar most other students took, which was New York. What shocks me here is that New Jersey, which is high on the difficultly list on this chart, is supposed to be incredibly easy from what I’ve heard. This information comes to me from people studying for both NY and NJ at the same time, so it seems possible that this chart isn’t really telling the full story. I am told you need to do nothing much beyond your study for the multistate bar to pass the NJ bar exam.
This leads me to consider the possibility that there are just a few truly difficult bar exams out there. The rest are considerably easier, but still are failed a lot because of the numerous reasons people have for failing bars. My thinking is that very few people probably study as hard for the NJ bar as they would for the NY bar, but they still fail because they studied less than was necessary despite the lower amount of study required.
In the end, all one can do is theorize about the objective differences between the bars, because it’s not possible to have the same group of people take all of them as if it was their first time taking the bar. Still, the clear take away from looking at the chart is that some bar exams are incredibly easy compared to others.
Just so we all know, by far the easiest bar is Wisconsin’s bar, provided you went to law school in the state. Wisconsin has a “diploma privilege” such that these students don’t even have to take the bar to pass and become full lawyers!
However, after all that analysis it appears that the South Dakota bar is still the easiest one to take if you actually are forced to take one.
15 Comments
This is an outstanding post that’s filled with so many useful nuggets. Thank you for being so detailed on bar exam.
What is not being taken into account in the statistics are how many graduates from ABA accredited schools pass the exam and what is their pass rate. In california for example the pass rate for first time takers from ABA schools is over 85%. I personally found the California exam extremely easy. I have taken four bars and found Cali to be the least challenging.
Not sure where you get 85% from, because the most-recent California bar exam results are published here.
Why are there only 48 states listed?
I am to lazy to try to find out which states are not listed.
Delaware and Alaska
Delaware is not there
Wisconsin students that complete law school in Wisconsin are not required to take the bar exam. That is why the pass rate appears to be so high on the chart above. It is called Diploma Privilege.
No not evry body can get the diploma privilege .
This list is very old. Wisconsin bar Feb 2016 was 55 percent.
The MBE is the issue, especially, if your jurisdiction weights the total score by a person’s MBE score. The MBE is a very difficult exam. A bar examiner has 1.8 minutes per question to read and answer each question. Two of the answers get thrown out but the remaining two split microscopic hairs. The question can run 1-2 pages in length. It is mentally and physically grueling. All of the local days for a bar exam are easier than the MBE. Forget the LSAT comparison and correlate data for the score on local day only or MBE score vs. local day score and whether or not the jurisdiction weights the total score by the MBE score. In NY, they give more weight to the MBE score and weight the total score by the MBE score. If a bar examiner does not do well on the MBE, it is highly unlikely they will pass the bar. The NCBE is disingenuous when they blame the quality of the law students instead of it’s exam. Hogwash. The students are super bright. The MBE is a mean-spirited exam. Couple this with the idea that there are only so many lawyers a jurisdiction will license because they are afraid of the competition. Frankly, the NCBE and the Bar Examination Committees should stop the paranoic nonsense and start treating the legal profession with respect. Compare too the treatment of a student accepted tip medical school. Once a student is accepted into medical school absolutely every effort is made by medical schools and everyone in the student’s formation to ensure the student becomes a licensed medical doctor. The same should happen for those choosing the legal profession. The vetting and screening happens before a student enters the professional school, not after. Once in the professional school, then everything should be done to help the student become the professional they signed up to become. The legal profession’s licensing and failure to have 100% reciprocity nationwide is a disgrace.
Well well said!!!
Nice
I think the pass/fail rates used in this analysis must be old… The Michigan pass rate is now quite low, whereas this analysis makes it look like the 9th easiest one.
i would like to know how you received a 177 on the LSAT?
Take a look at this article: LSAT Prep Books & Self-Study – How I got a 177 on the LSAT